Why Basement Smoke Evacuation Is One of the Most Common Challenges in Residential Projects
In every residential project that includes a basement level — and in practice, the vast majority of multi-story projects in Israel do — the question of basement smoke evacuation comes up at some point. Not always at the right point. Sometimes it arrives late, after the design is already set, the structural layout approved, and it suddenly becomes clear there is no shaft, no opening, and no room to implement what is required.
This is a topic that occupies architects, project management companies (PMC), and developers in almost every residential tower — whether the building is five stories or twin towers exceeding 42 meters. The dynamic is similar: storage rooms on the basement level, a closed space, and a question that someone needs to answer clearly and as early as possible.
Those who know this problem from the inside understand that the solution does not come from a single page or a list of equipment. It comes from understanding the space.
"I get involved at the stage where it is still possible to design the building around fire safety — not to force fire safety into it afterward."— Saar Udi, Fire Safety Consultant
The Problem: Underground Basements — Enclosed, Extended, with Few Air Openings
Basement storage rooms are, from a planning perspective, among the most challenging spaces for smoke management. The reason is simple: they are below grade. That means no windows, no facades exposed to outside air, and often long rows of individual storage units along extended corridors.
Smoke, which naturally rises, has nowhere to go when there is no exit. It fills the space, blocks escape routes, and prevents rescue teams from operating effectively. And if a solution is not planned in advance — it is not always possible to correct this once the structural frame is already in place.
The characteristics that make the solution more difficult:
- Depth: The deeper the storage rooms are below grade, the harder it is to reach a natural smoke exhaust opening.
- Geometry: Long corridors with storage units on both sides create airflow and smoke distribution problems.
- Lack of openings: Buildings with full site coverage — for example, where a commercial podium sits above — have no direct street-level exposure at all.
- Compartment subdivision: There are often several separate storage compartments, each of which requires an independent solution.
Each of these factors — and certainly their combination — requires design-level attention that comes from understanding the building as a whole, not just from knowing the written requirements.
The Two Common Solutions and How to Choose Between Them
When designing a smoke evacuation solution for underground basements, there are two primary approaches. The choice between them is not arbitrary — it follows from the specific parameters of the project.
Natural smoke evacuation: Based on openings that allow smoke to exit and cooler replacement air to enter — creating airflow. Suitable in situations where part of the space can be exposed to the outside environment, for example through openings in perimeter walls or at the vehicle ramp. Highly limited where there is no access to outside air.
Mechanical smoke extraction: Based on a fan (or multiple fans) that forcibly exhausts smoke through a shaft or duct to a discharge point outside the building. This approach can resolve situations where there are no natural openings, but it requires planning the fan location, the shaft, and the smoke discharge point — all of which need to be accommodated within the building.
Sometimes the solution is hybrid — some compartments handled naturally, others mechanically. There is no single formula that fits every project. What does exist is a fundamental principle: the earlier the question is asked, the more options are available.
When to Ask the Question — and What Happens When It Is Asked Too Late
The ideal stage to bring a fire safety consultant into the smoke evacuation question is the schematic design stage — when decisions are still being made about shaft locations, mechanical rooms, and the balance between storage, parking, and circulation. This is the stage at which a fire safety solution can be an organic part of the design.
What happens when it is raised too late? At the detailed drawings stage, every new required shaft demands a structural change. At the permit submission stage, every change can delay approval by months. And during construction, changes like these turn into wall works, structural cuts, and additional pipe runs — all of which come with a price tag.
There is also a problem that is harder to put a price on: when the solution is not designed upfront and then has to be "forced in" — it is often inelegant. A shaft that lands in an inconvenient location, a smoke discharge opening that conflicts with the architectural facade, a fan that is too far from the problem it needs to solve. The building does not wait for decisions — it accepts whatever solution is imposed on it.
"The great moments are not the fire that happened. They are the fire that did not happen."— Saar Udi
Case Study: Netivot 301 Project
The Netivot 301 project was one in which the question was raised at the right stage — and that made all the difference.
Netivot 301 — Twin Residential Towers Exceeding 42 Meters
The project comprised two residential towers each exceeding 42 meters in height, built above a commercial structure. The roof of the commercial building served as a green roof — and simultaneously as the separation roof between the two towers. This created a unique challenge: how to handle smoke evacuation for the basement storage compartments, where each tower includes its own basement storage level and the green roof limits the options for a direct smoke discharge path.
The work included a complete mapping of all compartments, defining a smoke evacuation solution that accounted for both safety requirements and the green roof design constraints, and coordinating with the project's overall requirements. The finalized solution integrated into the design without conflicting with the green roof components.
Israel Fire and Rescue Authority approval: approximately two months from submissionThe takeaway from this project is not "how quickly we received approval" — it is that approval was granted without delays because the solution was complete and professionally documented at the time of submission. When documentation is submitted in the language the regulator understands, a fast response follows. When documentation is submitted incomplete, a cycle of questions and responses begins that can stretch for months.