Skip to main content
📋 Case Study · Mixed-Use Residential & Commercial

Mixed-Use Residential & Commercial Project — 4 Fire Safety Challenges, Fire Authority Approval in Two Months, Zero Design Changes

✍️ Saar Udi · 📅 June 2026 · 🏢 New Construction — 7 Buildings · 5,000 m² Commercial Center · 💰 Project Value: approx. ₪300M
~2 Months
Submission to Fire Authority approval — faster than average
4
Complex fire safety challenges resolved in a single submission
0
Material design changes — documentation corrections only

When a fire safety consultant joins a project at the initial design stage, costly design revisions can be prevented down the line. When they join late — they arrive to solve problems that could have been resolved far more cheaply.

The Project: 7 Buildings, a Commercial Center, and Four Challenges

A large-scale new construction project: a 5,000 m² commercial center with 7 residential buildings above it — 5 buildings up to 29 meters tall and two 24-story towers. The roof of the commercial center serves as a green roof for the two towers. The project includes an aboveground parking garage with access routes that have no turning loop. Each building includes basement levels with storage unit wings. Project value: approximately ₪300 million.

The project management company engaged Saar Udi as the project's fire safety consultant from the initial stage. That early engagement was the right decision — and the reason becomes clear when examining each of the four challenges that needed to be resolved.

The Four Core Challenges

Challenge 1

Aboveground Parking — Access Routes Without a Turning Loop

Two separate access routes to the aboveground parking garage exceeded the 46-meter reversing limit under NFPA 1 — and faced a hard constraint: the ground-floor apartment gardens could not be altered.

Challenge 2

Green Roof with Technical Shafts

The commercial center's roof serves as a green roof for the two residential towers — leaving no room for visible technical installations. Mechanical shafts rising to the roof level threatened to disrupt the green roof design and landscaped areas.

Challenge 3

Smoke Extraction from Basement Storage Wings

Each building includes basement levels with storage unit wings. An incorrect system choice would result in property damage and impaired evacuation capability during an emergency.

Challenge 4

Fire Compartmentation — Commercial vs. Residential

Clear fire separation between commercial areas and the residential towers, and within the commercial spaces themselves — in compliance with regulatory requirements.

What Could Have Gone Wrong

In a ₪300 million project, every delay translates to millions in tied-up capital. Beyond the financial risk, each challenge carried direct safety consequences:

Parking Access Routes — Risk to Life and Property

A fire engine unable to maneuver through the parking access routes means delayed suppression and rescue operations — while also risking damage to vehicles during high-pressure maneuvering. Every delay in fire suppression equals greater property damage and a greater threat to human life.

Smoke Extraction — Risk of Trapping Occupants

An inadequate smoke evacuation system in basement storage areas does not only cause property damage — it compromises the ability of occupants to escape and can trap people in the building.

Three Creative Solutions

Solution 1: The Staging Area as a Turning Point

The standard solution for a parking garage without a turning loop is to create a dedicated turning area — but that would have required one of two compromises: eliminating parking spaces or encroaching on the ground-floor apartment gardens. Both were immediately ruled out.

Viewing the project as a whole — not as an isolated parking problem — opened an option that had not been considered: the staging forecourt of the adjacent buildings, located along the access route, could serve as the turning point for the fire engine. The solution met NFPA 1 requirements, and not a single parking space was lost.

✅ Result

All parking spaces retained. Apartment gardens untouched. The fire engine is able to complete the required maneuver in an emergency.

Solution 2: Raised Planters — Concealing Shafts Within the Design

The commercial center's roof serves as a green roof for the two residential towers — making it both functional and aesthetically significant. The problem: mechanical shafts rising from the lower floors must reach the roof, but there was no location that would not compromise the landscaping.

An architectural background gained early in Saar's professional career came into play: raised planter beds not intended for public use can serve as visual screening for technical shafts. The shafts rise within those raised planters — invisible from ground level, yet still accessible for maintenance.

✅ Result

The green roof preserved its appearance. Technical shafts were installed without affecting the design. A solution that begins with understanding the space — not just knowing the standard.

Solution 3: Ground-Level Smoke Discharge — Not Rooftop

The standard method for basement storage smoke extraction is routing ductwork up to the building roof — an average shaft height of 23 meters, a large fan unit, and high installation cost. The developer assumed that was the required approach.

Under Israeli Standard 1001 (TI 1001) for smoke extraction ducts, the smoke extraction duct can instead be routed toward the ground floor and discharged outside through a dedicated grill unit positioned clear of landscaped areas — a duct run of approximately 15 meters only.

Practical Difference

15 meters of ductwork instead of 23 meters. A smaller fan unit. Lower installation cost. Simpler maintenance. And a solution that frees up roof space for other building systems.

✅ Result

The developer changed position after a detailed technical briefing. The solution was approved by the Israel Fire and Rescue Authority. Fewer shafts rising to the roof means more residential floor area, and smaller fan units mean lower running costs.

Any problem can be solved in isolation — but you have to make sure that solving one problem does not create a problem somewhere else. The true value of a fire safety consultant is measured by the ability to see the project as a single integrated system.

Submission to the Fire Authority and Approval

1
Engagement at the Initial Design Stage
Integrated into the project consulting team from the outset — not as an external party called in retrospectively, but as part of the design team.
2
Identification of the Four Challenges
Comprehensive review of the entire project: parking garage, green roof, basements, and fire compartmentation — treated as a single system, not as separate problems.
3
Solution Development — Dialogue with the Team
Presenting solutions to the architect, the traffic consultant, and the developer — with a professional explanation for each. Three parties who initially thought differently; three conversations that ended in agreement.
4
Submission of Plans to the Fire Authority
A consolidated fire safety plan submission covering all four topics — submitted together, not piecemeal.
5
Revisions — Documentation Only
The Fire Authority requested revisions — all at the level of visual clarification and additional documentation. Not a single design change.
6
Fire Authority Approval — Within Approximately Two Months
All four topics approved. The developer received the building permit and construction commenced — significantly faster than the average for projects of this type.

Results

🚗
0 Spaces Lost
Not a single parking space was eliminated — all retained for the developer
💰
Hundreds of Thousands ₪
Up to several million — saved by avoiding unnecessary over-engineering
🌿
Green Roof Intact
Technical shafts concealed without any impact on the design

The Lesson: What Early Engagement Actually Delivers

A fire safety consultant who joins a project late — just before the Fire Authority submission — can also reach the same solutions. But there is one critical difference: a solution discovered at a late stage requires a design change. A design change on a project of this scale means returning to the planning and building committee for a revised permit — a delay of months and significant costs already at the design stage.

The early engagement on this project enabled something simple yet profound: to see the parking garage, the green roof, the basements, and the compartmentation not as separate problems — but as a single integrated system that needs to be solved in harmony.

What Architects and Project Managers Need to Understand

A fire safety consultant who joins at the initial stage is not "just another consultant adding requirements." They are part of the team ensuring that what gets built will be approved — and saving the cost of changes further down the line.

Planning a Residential, Commercial, or Mixed-Use Project?

The earlier you bring in fire safety expertise, the fewer surprises along the way. No-cost introductory consultation.

Let's Discuss Your Project
S

Saar Udi

Fire Safety Consultant & Risk Manager

Over 20 years of fire safety planning experience, formerly with the Fire Protection Division of the Israel Fire and Rescue Authority. Has worked on hundreds of projects — residential, commercial, industrial, and public buildings. Specializes in early-stage engagement to prevent costly design revisions down the line.